EXD'11: Useless, an exploded view

EXD'11: Useless, an exploded view

In this Q&A, curator Jonathan Olivares defends and explores the useless side of design with an intriguing conceptual exhibit A design report from Lisbon by Elena Sommariva

The exhibition Useless, an exploded view curated by American designer Jonathan Olivares at MUDE, Lisbon's fashion and design museum, responds to the unlikely theme of the "Useless" in the sixth edition of the EXD'11 biennial, and elicits great curiosity by asking visitors to sit at a 40-meter long table to observe and study the objects on display. More than a conventional design exhibit, the proposal is a kind of three-dimensional library that invites the viewer to understand and discuss the causes, manifestations and collateral effects of uselessness in the design, production and distribution of today's industrial products.

Elena Sommariva: What are the objectives of this exhibition? For what type of audience is it meant?
Jonathan Olivares:
The exhibition is made for people to explore, so I don't want to tell you everything. The exhibition started with two objectives: to create a group of objects that would tell a story about uselessness, but you can't understand uselessness without understanding usefulness. Some objects here are quite useful and some others are not. The question is: is it useful or not? And I don't really pose the answer. The second thing we wanted to do with this exhibition is take a story and put it in a three dimensional library, where you can take your time, go with friends, have conversations. I used to study a lot at the New York Public Library, and it was so inspiring to work there.

Installation view of the exhibition Useless, an exploded view curated by Jonathan Olivares at MUDE, Lisbon, on view until November 26.
Testo alternativo Immagine Installation view of the exhibition Useless, an exploded view curated by Jonathan Olivares at MUDE, Lisbon, on view until November 26.

Could you explain the idea behind the exhibition set-up, which is so minimal?
It is partly because of [MUDE's] very sci-fi space, the space is why we did this exhibition design. We came to see it in June and we decided to really prioritize the exhibition design around it. We made this table, very classic, simple, like a library table, we used the Enzo Mari chairs and we think that everything that isn't on the table had to be very functional, super-useful; and that instead, everything on the table is a question.

Usually visitors read the captions of an exhibition. Here, instead, everyone has in hand a little booklet....
The booklet is a very important part of the exhibition. When you arrive, this is the first thing you see. You take the book and you enter the space. Without the book, you cannot understand the structure of the exhibition. Once you enter the space, you can take your time, choose what to look at. At the beginning of the book we wrote, Caution this is our opinion, this is a library for debate, and like a library it does not have an opinion. It is a tool for discussion. And it is great to see people talking. We also wanted to make people laugh and feel uncomfortable in these situations. And I think we got it.

Installation view of the exhibition Useless, an exploded view curated by Jonathan Olivares at MUDE, Lisbon, on view until November 26.
Testo alternativo Immagine Installation view of the exhibition Useless, an exploded view curated by Jonathan Olivares at MUDE, Lisbon, on view until November 26.

How did you make the curatorial selection?
We have chapters: Useless by Design, Useless is Up to the User, Useless Happens, Useless Side Effects, Useless is Contagious, Too Much of a Useful thing is Useless, and Useless is Overrated. I wanted to collect a very wide range of things to tell all the different perspectives of what is useful. I wanted to look not only at how useless happens in terms of design, but also in the production and disposal of objects. At the causes both cultural, industrial and personal, "Who is responsible for useless?"; "Is it the user?"; "Is it the manufacturer?"; "The designer?" There are so many different answers. We propose eight different questions. We don't try to give answers, it's not a dogmatic exhibition. It's a didactic exhibition, a place where you can learn.

"We propose eight different questions. We don't try to give answers, it's not a dogmatic exhibition. It's a didactic exhibition, a place where you can learn."

Installation view of the exhibition Useless, an exploded view curated by Jonathan Olivares at MUDE, Lisbon, on view until November 26.
Testo alternativo Immagine Installation view of the exhibition Useless, an exploded view curated by Jonathan Olivares at MUDE, Lisbon, on view until November 26.

The first section is called Useless by Design.
We basically say here: anytime that mankind takes a material from the earth and manipulates it into something else, we make a decision that excludes all the other possibilities. Useless happens first and always because someone made a decision: market, designers, institution, government, whoever; even just a craftsman with a piece of wood.

One of the things about this exhibit is that I wanted to look at all kind of emotions related to product design. Let me jump to the Castiglioni stool; why is it useless? The stool is like a surgical blade, like a club… If you don't have a certain skill, you cannot use these things. Everybody can sit on this stool, but the people who can pay 1,000 euros for it are not buying it to sit on it; they are buying it because they understand Castiglioni's work and that he was influenced by Duchamp, or Man Ray, and he was saying for the first time: ok it is acceptable to make a ready-made into design. This stool is actually very uncomfortable, if you don't understand this, you are missing the point.

Installation view of the exhibition Useless, an exploded view curated by Jonathan Olivares at MUDE, Lisbon, on view until November 26.
Testo alternativo Immagine Installation view of the exhibition Useless, an exploded view curated by Jonathan Olivares at MUDE, Lisbon, on view until November 26.

So, we can say that useless is up to the user?
Without those years of practice and training and knowledge, surgical blades can cause more damage than good. But with these skills, with practical training they can save a life. An untrained user will make things useless.
The skateboarders are very interesting to me for more than a reason. They require a skill that allows them to turn useless infrastructures into useful obstacles. They have the funny capability to turn parking lots, boring spaces, or totally banal things like curbs, into something magical. They are so good and so beautiful to watch. If you can't be inventive enough to figure out how to use something, it's useless. Enzo Mari said that when the bag was first invented was very important for the evolution of the mankind, because it gave pleasure to humans. Because they could store food, they could hang out, that's when pleasure begins. Charles Eames said: "Who said that pleasure is not useful?" Ironically, the skateboard was invented in Venice Beach, two blocks from where Eames had his office and it uses the same technology that Eames used: moulded die-cast aluminium poli and wheels.

Installation view of the exhibition Useless, an exploded view curated by Jonathan Olivares at MUDE, Lisbon, on view until November 26.
Testo alternativo Immagine Installation view of the exhibition Useless, an exploded view curated by Jonathan Olivares at MUDE, Lisbon, on view until November 26.

What are the side effects of the useless?
Anything that is practically useless has a kind of users repercussion, a side effect.
These are samples of Grcic chairs that occasionally arrived in the office, every time they change colour in the mould, you have three or four in-between chairs, with wrong colours. They are trash, they are thrown away immediately. Our society doesn't value them. But they are beautiful, they are like tropical fish.
So this is not a design exhibition per se, it is an exhibition about life and everyday reality and how products fit in this reality. And how they are useless or useful in this reality. I think that Kleenex is useless, I prefer handkerchiefs. Convenience is the most important collaborator of the useless.

Installation view of the exhibition Useless, an exploded view curated by Jonathan Olivares at MUDE, Lisbon, on view until November 26.
Testo alternativo Immagine Installation view of the exhibition Useless, an exploded view curated by Jonathan Olivares at MUDE, Lisbon, on view until November 26.

A section of the exhibition is dedicated to design and architecture magazines. Do you think they are useless?
If a hundred people buy a coffee table, and put it in their houses, maybe 10,000 have seen it in person at the Salone del Mobile, ICFF or in a retail store. 100,000 people have seen an image of it in a magazine or on the Internet. It is a question of what role does the media have in design, which is obviously a positive thing, but also calls into question the quality of journalism. We can say that the average design magazine has a standard in criticism and journalism so low that it can suit a high school newspaper. You have to satisfy your monthly deadline, fresh news each month. Like for the Salone, you have to arrive with new products each year.

How is usefulness overrated?
I think we have a cultural and infrastructural crisis right now. The amount of products we are making just to give people jobs is kind of scary.

Installation view of the exhibition Useless, an exploded view curated by Jonathan Olivares at MUDE, Lisbon, on view until November 26.
Testo alternativo Immagine Installation view of the exhibition Useless, an exploded view curated by Jonathan Olivares at MUDE, Lisbon, on view until November 26.

Your activity is split in two—design and theory—and the research part is becoming more relevant. How important is it for a designer nowadays to reflect on his profession?
Jeff Koons said: "There are as many ways to make art as there are artists". I think that no designer in the world works with bad intentions. These people love their work. I am still very focused on products. I am definitely designing. But personally I am doing at maximum one product per year. Right now I have a very good relationship with Knoll in the United States. I can do an exhibition in six months because it will last for three months. But a product that potentially will be on the market for years, we have to spend time on this. We are taking it slow. We can work on a single product for four years.

We are approaching the end of the table and the end of the exhibition....
I am ending with a happy and optimistic note. Here you have an American t-shirt in different colours. We said: "Does the world need a t-shirt in every single colour? No, absolutely not. Is it nice to have them all? Yes". The nice about life is that need and nice are not the same thing. And usefulness is overrated when it comes to design.
Again we are going back to Eames, who said that the pleasure is useful. And I totally agree.

Installation view of the exhibition Useless, an exploded view curated by Jonathan Olivares at MUDE, Lisbon, on view until November 26.
Testo alternativo Immagine Installation view of the exhibition Useless, an exploded view curated by Jonathan Olivares at MUDE, Lisbon, on view until November 26.

EXD'11: Useless

A week before its opening, director Guta Moura Guedes tells Domus about the main events in the Portuguese design biennale and the thinking that inspired it A design report from Lisbon by Elena Sommariva

EXD'11: Action for Age

12 design solutions to improve the quality of life of the elderly, based on building intergenerational relationships A design report from Lisbon

Konstantin Grcic: the Pro chair for students

Grcic's new seating for the German company Flötotto, soon to be unveiled at Cologne, emerges as a case study for an innovative type of production that is often overlooked An interview from Cologne by Loredana Mascheroni

Add your annotation here
Testo alternativo Immagine
Testo alternativo Immagine Close
Testo alternativo Immagine